Skip to product information
1 of 3

Mystery NYC Stuffed Cookies Box - 4 Pack

Mystery NYC Stuffed Cookies Box - 4 Pack

Regular price £18.00 GBP
Regular price Sale price £18.00 GBP
Sale Sold out
Tax included.

Dolly's Mystery NYC Stuffed Cookie Box - 4 Pack

Every order will include :

4 x Dolly's Stuffed Cookies

per mystery box

There is a total of 14 different flavours in the selection pool. 

This weeks primary flavours are marked with an astericks*

You will receive 4 stuffed cookies of the following flavours:

  • Birthday Cake Stuffed Cookie
  • Biscoff Stuffed Cookie
  • Bueno & Nutella Stuffed Cookie
  • Cherry Bakewell Stuffed Cookie
  • Chocolate Brownie Stuffed Cookie
  • Cookies & Creme Stuffed Cookie
  • Freddo Stuffed Cookie
  • Guylian Stuffed Cookie
  • Milkybar Stuffed Cookie
  • Jammie Dodger Stuffed Cookie
  • Raspberry and White Chocolate Stuffed Cookie
  • Rolo Stuffed Cookie
  • Smores Stuffed Cookie
  • Snickers Stuffed Cookie

Flavours may vary. Although we try our best to pack flavour requests, you are not guaranteed to receive any particular flavour of stuffed cookie and there is a possibility that you may receive duplicate flavours. 


We understand that you may have allergies or dietary requirements meaning some of our bakes may not be suitable.

If there are any specific flavours which are not suitable, please let us know within the order notes. We try our best to accomodate for any requests, however due to the mystery nature of this box we cannot guarantee specific flavours.

Allergens are displayed on the back of each cookie packet.

Click here to view all cookie allergens.

Please note, that although we take upmost care to avoid cross contamination this product is made in a kitchen which handles other allergens. Therefore this product may contain traces of soya and nuts (if not listed in the ingredients).

Storage & Shelf Life

Postal bakes are shipped out the day after they are baked. Each box lasts 8-10 days. A best before date can be found on the bottom of each individual brownie.

Cookies should be stored in an airtight container and kept at room temperature.

Our cookies can also be frozen. These last up to 3 months in the freezer. Just take one out and pop in the microwave to enjoy.

Additional Information

We love to pop our stuffed cookies in the microwave for 30 seconds, so that the spread inside melts.

Serve with a drizzle of our Dolly's Dessert Toppings for the full experience.

Delivery Information

Orders are sent by DPD and delivered across the UK with next day delivery.

Delivery notifications are sent over text/email from DPD.

Shipping fee is £4.99

View full details